Whom can I sue in Federal Court?
Written by Rockefeller Law Center
On its face, the Civil Rights Act does NOT apply to the Federal Government. Remember, it was passed in reaction to the Civil War and was one of the "Reconstruction Laws," specifically passed with the recalcitrant Confederate states in mind. Thus, you cannot directly sue the United States Government, or any of its entities, for violating the Civil Rights Act. However, in 1971, the United States Supreme Court permitting suit against individual federal employees, in limited circumstances, for something known as a "Bivens" action.

States cannot be sued directly in Federal Courts for money damages without their permission, due to the application of the 11th Amendment to our Constitution; but, they can be sued in Federal Courts for "prospective relief." For example, if a State operates an overcrowded prison system, a private person can sue to eliminate the overcrowding, but not to recover any money damages for having had to endure the overcrowding.

 

This does NOT mean that the Civil Rights Act has no application against States. First, in theory, you could sue a State in "State" Court, alleging a Civil Rights Act violation; although, it is not often an "entity" is responsible for a civil rights violation. Second, and more importantly, individual State actors can be sued in Federal Courts. For instance, in the prison setting, a prison guard can be sued for beating up a prisoner and, typically, the State will pay for any damages awarded.

With the popular notion of governments "outsourcing" governmental functions to private agencies, it is of increasing importance in modern life that private entities and actors can also be sued in Federal Court for violations of a person’s civil rights. This is true if a private entity or actor performs a traditional governmental function (like "private" prisons or probation), those who contract with governmental entities, or those who cause a governmental entity or actor to violate a person’s civil rights (like falsely accusing someone of a crime or in a conspiracy).



Top

For more information, or any questions or comments, please contact us.


Rockefeller Law Center   |   524 S. Houston Lake Road   |   Suite G-100   |   Warner Robins, Ga 31088
Phone (478) 953-6955
Detailed Contact Information   |  [Map]

Copyright © 2007— Rockefeller Law Center — All Rights Reserved
Privacy Statement
FAMA The Rockefeller Report Jim Rockefeller Christine M. Cruise Jim Rockefeller Christine M. Cruise